top of page

Leaders Have Untapped Talent and Don’t Even Realize It

Nov 8
4 min read
A professional working quietly by a window while colleagues meet in the foreground of a bright office.

Think about what it looks like to lead a team right now. Hours were cut somewhere along the way so the company could stay afloat, which means some of the people who know the work best are part-time, and when something comes up that one of them used to just handle as part of the job, you can’t ask, because there are no hours allocated for it. You have a role open and the applications come back through a screening tool, so the list you see is short, and in the meantime the work goes to the people you already know can get it done.


From where you sit it looks like the talent is not out there, and a lot of leaders are saying the same thing right now while they talk about all of the jobs they have open and want to fill.


I think leaders have access to untapped talent, and they don’t even realize it.


Counted as Employed, and Very Underemployed

A lot of that talent is already on the payroll. Companies have been learning how to do more with less, and for many of them it was easier to cut hours than to let staff go altogether, which kept what those employees know inside the building and gave the company some continuity of intellectual capital while it worked to stay afloat.


The other side of that decision is that leaders can’t tap into those employees as freely as they used to. Anything outside their reduced hours now has to be allocated in time and money, so it stops being something they just do, and if someone has twenty hours a week for what used to be forty hours of work, you can’t expect forty hours of output in twenty. That’s just not going to happen.


The jobs report counts every one of them as employed, and in October there were 4.8 million people working part-time because they couldn’t get more hours, 339,000 more than the month before. That is a lot of underutilized talent, and many of the same companies are trying to hire from the outside to get the work done.


Screened Out Before Anyone Looks

Hiring from the outside runs into a different problem, which is the screen. Companies say the jobs are open and they want to hire, and much of the screening is now done by tools, so if a resume doesn’t line up to the T, a qualified candidate can be excluded from the pool over a missed word or letter, something very trivial. Meanwhile two million people have been out of work for six months or longer, more than a quarter of everyone who is unemployed.


Early-career candidates have it harder still. They’re screened out for not having the experience, and with costs being cut and tools doing the screening, it’s a lot harder for them to get in the door at all. These are recent graduates with so much to offer, who could bring valuable insight into a place that may have groupthink, and none of what’s happening to them or to the part-time employee down the hall shows up in a headline that only counts who is working.


Another Perspective: Look Past the Headline

We need to look at what’s past the headlines. The conversation keeps returning to how many people are employed and how many aren’t, when the questions that matter more are why leaders can’t find the right candidates and why the employees they already have are so underutilized.


My view is that nine times out of ten the talent is there, inside the company and in the applicant pool, and it’s being overlooked because it hasn’t been given the opportunity. When time is tight, leaders turn to whoever they know can get it done, and when a tool hands back a shortlist they take it, because the tool was put in place to make things more efficient. Tools have made hiring easier, but accepting the answer you’re given on the first try means the candidates who could have brought something new are never looked at. Reaching that talent comes down to a few habits.


Where to Start

Each one asks for a little more diligence than relying on the screen or the usual go-to person.


Get to know the people who work for you. Hold consistent one-on-ones, weekly if you can, use them to understand each person’s strengths and weaknesses, and then give them opportunities to grow or stretch. Much of the untapped talent in a company sits with employees who have simply been overlooked, and this is how you find them.


Give the work to someone new. Under a deadline, the pull is to hand it to the person you know will deliver. Get past that discomfort and push against the timeline a little if you need to, so someone else gets the chance to learn and do it. Someone coming to a problem fresh will tackle it in ways others wouldn’t have thought of, and that different perspective is needed.


Hire for what isn’t on paper. Make sure your recruiter gets to know the role they are recruiting for, beyond the job description, including the characteristics, skills and behaviors that make someone a good fit. If you can tell them what isn’t on the paper, they’ll find those candidates. Don’t rely only on the tool that may be filtering them out, either. Get your hands dirty and look at who’s applying.


The headline will keep counting who is employed and who isn’t, and it won’t show who is underused or who was screened out over a word on a resume. That only comes into view when a leader goes looking. Spending time with your people and giving them the opportunity brings new skills, perspectives and points of view into the work, and it can help liven things up and get the work done more efficiently. It takes a little more diligence, and the talent is there for the leaders willing to do the work and figure it out.


Also published in my LinkedIn newsletter, What Nobody’s Saying. 


If this sounds like your team, my free guide, The Problem You Keep Fixing, is available here:


If you’d like to talk about what this looks like in your organization, you can start a conversation here.


Sources

[1] U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2026). The Employment Situation, October 2026.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page